What you need to know about spam and blacklists

A yellowed list full of crossed-out lines on a noticeboard

What are spam blacklists?

Spam blacklists are lists of, for example, internet addresses, websites and email senders that have been used by spammers in the past. Such a blacklist is sometimes used to determine whether something is spam or not. This seems handy, but very often spam filters go wrong precisely because they use a blacklist.

The drawbacks of spam blacklists

The advantages of a blacklist speak for themselves, but the drawbacks are less obvious. We list the most important ones here, each with a short explanation:

  • Spam blacklists are often out of date: sometimes the information on them is no longer valid even at the moment it is added. Computers change location, people change email addresses and websites change owners. Not every blacklist is well maintained, and sometimes even well-maintained blacklists can lead to wrongful spam classifications.

 

  • Information on a blacklist is often incorrect: most spammers, for example, often use stolen email addresses of innocent senders and pepper their spam with links to innocent websites. All this to wrong-foot the makers of blacklists.
  • Blacklists say nothing about the content of an email: your internet provider may, for example, be on a blacklist, but that does not mean that all email sent through that provider is spam.

So the big drawback of blacklists is that email is wrongly flagged as spam. Many free or very cheap anti-spam solutions rely entirely or largely on blacklists. Some even go so far as to reject email unseen if there is a blacklist listing! The result is almost always very mediocre spam filtering, combined with a relatively large number of ‘lost’ emails that were wrongly filtered out. For consumer purposes this may be acceptable, but in the business market it is, in our view, an absolute cardinal sin.

How does Onlinespamfilter deal with this?

Unfortunately, blacklists are not a good means of recognising spam. Onlinespamfilter therefore really only uses them as a supporting element in our final analysis. Messages are always scanned and assessed in their entirety. A blacklist can never on its own be responsible for a classification as spam. This balanced spam filtering takes a little more work from our hardware and software, but results in a spam filter of very high quality!