Today’s spam: Increasingly ‘on target’

A fishing hook with an envelope as bait in front of a laptop

A friend supposedly asking you to transfer money, an ‘uncle’ warning you about a new virus, an unexpected request from your financial adviser to confirm your details: these days spam is a highly personal matter. How did we get here? And what is the next step?

Proud of spam

When DEC sends an advertisement to _all_users on ARPANET (the forerunner of the internet) in 1978, the very first spam campaign is a fact. It reaches a few hundred users. The first large-scale commercial spam follows in 1994. The American law firm Canter & Siegel, based in Phoenix, posts a message to thousands of Usenet newsgroups telling readers they are eligible for a visa through the green card lottery. The firm would, for a fee of course, take care of the necessary paperwork. These spammers make no effort to hide their identity; in fact, they are rather proud of their clever advertising tactic.

Too good to be true

Then things go rapidly downhill. In 1997 spammers start hacking other people’s servers for the first time, so they can send spam from other domains. In 2000 the first Nigerian scams turn up: the fraudsters who tell you that a distant uncle in South Africa has left you a nice sum of money. All you have to do is pay an advance fee to have the inheritance paid out… These too good to be true stories are not very convincing, but as long as a few in every thousand of the millions of recipients actually transfer money, the spammers have already made a handsome haul.

More targeted fishing

In 2003 the volume of spam overtakes ‘normal’ email traffic. Most of it is advertising: for Viagra and miracle cures for hair loss. But spam is also taking on increasingly criminal forms. The first major virus attacks break out. Trojan horses are becoming more and more common.

From 2007 the tide seems to turn, as better spam filters come onto the market. Emails with identical content sent by the hundreds of thousands per minute are easily filtered out. In response, internet criminals gradually change course and opt for a more personal approach. They start ‘fishing’ in a more targeted way (so-called ‘phishing’).

Spearphishing: individual spam

Conventional phishing emails – emails asking for personal details in the name of companies such as ING or Rabobank – are still sent in bulk, with an impersonal greeting and also to people who aren’t even customers of the bank in question; spearphishing targets specific individuals. Information about a person’s social circle is gathered, often via social media, and used to make the email more credible.
Every message is unique, the volume is much lower than it used to be, and emails are not sent all at once but, for example, every hour or every twenty minutes. Quite often this is even done from a contact’s hacked account; at first glance, not a suspicious email domain. Because such messages look so much like legitimate emails, they stay under the radar of spam filters for a long time.

Whaling: hunting for big fish

Going one step further is whaling, or spearphishing at senior management level. In this tactic, which is rapidly on the rise, sensitive company information is coaxed out of people in order to trick senior executives into unwittingly making large payments to criminals. Operations like this obviously take considerably more time and effort than casting tens of thousands of hooks in the hope that 1% ‘bites’. But the effort pays off, because if it works, the perpetrators have landed a really ‘big fish’.

Spam evolves, but so does spam fighting

Because of its small scale and personal approach, spearphishing is harder to tackle than other forms of spam. Still, content filters can do something about it, because they do spot trends. For example, we continually add new suspicious keywords to the database, such as ‘credit card expired’. Some spam, however, is so good that we humans have to read three paragraphs before we realise whether it is real or fake. And as long as people keep falling for it, machines will too. It will be quite a while yet before spam scanners stop making any mistakes at all, if it ever gets that far…

Until then, we manage to stop well over 99.9% of unwanted email, and you hardly have to give it a thought.